Follow this blog by Email

Sunday, August 16, 2020

US election: Military officials in extraordinary Trump letter

7 minutes to read

By: Jamie Seidel

President Trump's top military man has just been delivered an extraordinary request by two senior military staffers in a worst case scenario following the upcoming US election.

An open letter, published by online US military news site Defense One, is addressed to General Mark Milley, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and paints a stark picture of what the authors believe could emerge following the upcoming US election.

"As chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, you are well aware of your duties in ordinary times: to serve as principal military advisor to the president of the United States, and to transmit the lawful orders of the president and Secretary of Defense to combatant commanders," the letter reads.

"In ordinary times, these duties are entirely consistent with your oath to 'support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic…'

"We do not live in ordinary times. The president of the United States is actively subverting our electoral system, threatening to remain in office in defiance of our Constitution. In a few months' time, you may have to choose between defying a lawless president or betraying your Constitutional oath. We write to assist you in thinking clearly about that choice.

"If Donald Trump refuses to leave office at the expiration of his constitutional term, the United States military must remove him by force, and you must give that order."

Written by, John Nagl, a retired army officer and veteran of both Iraq wars and Paul Yingling, a retired lieutenant colonel who served three tours in Iraq, another in Bosnia, and a fifth in Operation Desert Storm, the letter gives voice to concerns that the next presidential election will become its most contentious in history.

The authors claim Trump is facing defeat in the November election and has engaged in a "systemic disinformation" campaign, along with other actions, that could see him throw doubt on results or refuse to leave office on 20 January 2021.

It comes amid allegations of foreign interference in the electoral process from Russia, China and Iran. Trump has previously been dismissive of claims of continued meddlings by Moscow. The White House, however, says it has serious concerns about Beijing.

Meanwhile, Trump has been actively campaigning against the postal vote system, calling it easily manipulated and a risk to the validity of the nation's choice.

The coronavirus pandemic, ensuing recession and Black Lives Matter protests have created a unique cocktail of anger and disenfranchisement that exploded across the US earlier this year following the death of George Floyd.

A recent report from Politico highlighted a "perfect storm" of eight factors including dislocated voters, foreign intereference and the situation in the White House that could be explosive in the upcoming vote.

Amid these fears, 67 experts have "war gamed" how a deeply divisive election campaign could play out.

They followed established patterns of behaviour and used campaign tactics that are already being deployed.

"Out of this war game, we witnessed role-players exercise power nakedly," retired Major General Paul Eaton observed. The resulting report was equally grim.

"We assess with a high degree of likelihood that November's elections will be marked by a chaotic legal and political landscape," says the Georgetown University's Transition Integrity Project, which organised the "war games".

"The winner may not, and we assess likely will not, be known on 'election night' as officials count mail-in ballots," the report says.

"This period of uncertainty provides opportunities for an unscrupulous candidate to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the process and to set up an unprecedented assault on the outcome."

One study found nearly one out of four voters – 22 per cent of Democrats and 21 per cent of Republicans – said some amount of "violence" would be justified if the candidate they oppose wins the White House. Some 29 per cent said violence would be justified if Trump loses the election but refused to leave.

Under such circumstances, the fate of the world's most powerful democracy would be at stake.

Trump's social media has been filled with claims about the election being 'rigged' leading some to suggest he could dispute the validity of the vote. Photo / AP

"Throughout our history, Americans have laid down their lives so that this form of government may endure," the open letter to General Milley reads.

"Continuing the unfinished work for which these heroes fell now falls to you.

"In the Constitutional crisis described above, your duty is to give unambiguous orders directing US military forces to support the constitutional transfer of power. Should you remain silent, you will be complicit in a coup d'├ętat."


  1. Basically their telling Trump orders may not be unconditionally obeyed. His world is finally collapsing around him, unfortunately it took 4 years. Generals, twitter, facebook, past presidents, religious leaders and even Fox news to some extent are standing up to the narcissist. Aren’t you glad you’re a Canadian?

    1. Rick, Over the past 3 years I have met many Americans who have asked me how they could become Canadians or at least emigrate to Canada. But reality is that it is almost impossible for Americans, unless they fit into a few immigration classes. One of them being marriage to a Canadian spouse. For the life of me I can't understand why anyone would want to live in the USA or become a US-citizen. And I say after I have travelled the US extensively for many years. I still love the land, but the political side of it is a nightmare.



We like to hear from you. You can add your comment here: